In Mafia (or Werewolf), the moderator wakes each role at night, collects their choices and announces who died. It is the one seat at the table that never gets to play. There are four common ways to play without giving up a player for it.
Guide
How to play Mafia without a moderator
Nobody wants to sit out and run the night. Here are the ways around it.
Four ways to run the night
Take turns moderating
How it works: A different person runs each game.
The catch: Someone always sits out, and new moderators slow the game down.
Cards and a caller
How it works: Deal role cards; one person calls the night with their eyes open.
The catch: The caller still cannot play, and their voice and pauses give things away.
A helper app for the moderator
How it works: One phone tells the moderator who to wake and what to say.
The catch: Easier to run, but the moderator still does not play.
An app that narrates the night
How it works: The app calls each role out loud and everyone picks on their own phone.
The catch: Every player needs a phone.
How a narrated night works
Everyone joins
Each player scans a QR code with their own phone. The code shows on the host's phone or on a TV.
Roles are dealt
The app deals the roles. Each player sees only their own, on their own screen.
The night is called out loud
A narrator voice tells the town to sleep, then wakes each role in turn.
Picks happen in silence
When your role is called, your phone wakes up and you pick a target. Everyone else's phone stays dark, so nothing at the table gives you away.
Dawn and the vote
The app announces who died, runs the day's discussion and vote, and checks who won.
What you need
- 4 to 30 players
- A phone for each player
- Optional: a TV or laptop to show the game to the whole room
Mafia: Circle of Lies does the narrating - free, no ads, in 10 languages.